November 6, 2026

Utomi and the Mathematics of Opposition Unity

By Dr. Festus Ogwuche
Nigeria’s opposition has discovered an old political truth with a new urgency which is that votes divided among several candidates may produce less political consequence than the same votes organised behind one coherent alternative. The difficulty, however, is that political arithmetic is rarely as simple as addition.
The initiative led by Professor Pat Utomi through the Movement for Credible Elections to bring opposition parties and presidential aspirants behind a single candidate therefore deserves attention not merely as another pre-election alliance, but as an experiment in whether Nigeria’s opposition can transform fragmentation into political organisation. The group says it is engaging shortlisted presidential candidates and their parties, with the objective of establishing transparent rules for selecting one candidate and producing a common governance programme. The parties identified include the ADC, PDP, SDP, APM, NDC, Accord, PRP, AAC and YPP.
The significance of the proposal lies precisely in what has frustrated previous attempts at opposition consolidation. Nigerian politicians have repeatedly discovered the virtue of unity in principle and the difficulty of unity when it requires somebody to surrender personal ambition. It is one thing to agree that the opposition should unite; it is another to decide who should lead the united opposition.
That is why the Utomi initiative has placed unusual emphasis on the process by which a candidate would emerge. Its stated criteria include national acceptability, competence, integrity, leadership profile, policy orientation, commitment to democratic institutions and the capacity to work across diverse social interests. More importantly, the group says participating candidates and parties would have to commit beforehand to respect the outcome and support the adopted candidate.
That may be the coalition’s most consequential proposition. A coalition cannot survive if every participant regards the selection process as legitimate only when he or she wins it.
 The harder question begins after the handshake.
Political support is not transferable property. The supporters of one candidate do not automatically become supporters of another merely because their preferred candidate signs an agreement. A politician may accept a compromise while some of his followers reject it and others may abstain. while some migrate to other political platforms. The arithmetic of adding political constituencies can therefore be profoundly different from the arithmetic of adding votes.
This makes candidate selection only the first test. The second is whether the coalition can create a sufficiently credible political identity to persuade Nigerians that it represents something more substantial than an anti-incumbency arrangement.
Utomi’s group appears conscious of this danger. It says the proposed coalition should not merely assemble political personalities but produce a common programme addressing insecurity, economic hardship, unemployment, poverty, institutional decay, electoral integrity, constitutional reform, education, healthcare, energy and the cost of governance.
That distinction could determine the practical meaning of the entire venture.
Nigeria does not simply need a coalition of politicians, but a coalition capable of explaining why these politicians have come together, what they intend to change and how they intend to govern together after the election. Otherwise, the exercise risks becoming another elite compact whose principal language is the distribution of officesx rather than the reconstruction of public institutions.
There is also a question of political architecture. If several parties retain their identities but endorse one presidential candidate, what happens to the legislative contests? Will the parties coordinate candidates for the National Assembly? Will they agree on a governing programme? How will disagreements over ministerial appointments, legislative leadership and constitutional reform be managed? What happens if the coalition’s presidential candidate wins but the constituent parties control different parts of the legislature?
These are not technical afterthoughts rather the difference between an electoral alliance and a governing coalition.
The timing makes the problem more acute. INEC has formally commenced the 2027 electoral process and published its timetable, while the Commission has also been dealing with legal questions surrounding nomination and substitution timelines.  The opposition therefore has less room for indefinite negotiation. At some point, consultation must become commitment, and commitment must become organisation.
There are already signs of the difficulty. Even among opposition figures there are differing views about the practicality of the Utomi-led process. While some have welcomed the initiative, others have questioned whether a single opposition candidate remains achievable.  That disagreement is not necessarily evidence of failure; it illustrates the central problem the initiative is attempting to solve.
The real test, therefore, is not whether Atiku Abubakar, Peter Obi, Seyi Makinde or any other aspirant can sit in the same room. It is whether they can construct rules under which each is prepared to accept a political outcome that may exclude him personally.
That requires something rarer than political calculation which basically is institutional trust.
The opposition also has to confront the possibility that unity can produce contradictions of its own. Different parties and aspirants have different constituencies, political histories and policy emphases. Bringing them together may enlarge the coalition’s geographical reach, but it can also expose disagreements that were previously concealed by separate candidacies. A coalition broad enough to encompass everybody may become so ideologically and politically elastic that voters cannot identify what it stands for.
The answer is not necessarily ideological uniformity, but clarity about the minimum programme on which the coalition is prepared to govern.
That is why the Utomi initiative should be judged less by the number of politicians it gathers and more by the institutional quality of the bargain it produces. A serious opposition coalition would need transparent rules for choosing its candidate, enforceable commitments by participating parties, ax common national programme, mechanisms for resolving internal disputes and a credible plan for translating electoral cooperation into governance.
The deeper question confronting Nigeria in 2027 is consequently larger than whether the opposition can defeat fragmentation. It is whether political actors can demonstrate that they understand the difference between winning an election and constructing a government.
While the first requires numbers, the second requires architecture.
Nigeria has seen enough alliances built around personalities and elections. What would be politically consequential now is an opposition arrangement capable of persuading citizens that its unity is not simply a temporary marriage of convenience, but a negotiated framework for governing a complex federation.
The mathematics of opposition unity, in the end, is not one plus one equals two, rather whether two political ambitions can become one political purpose, and whether that purpose can survive the moment when the votes have been counted.
Dr. Ogwuche is the President of the Campaign for Social Justice and Constitutional Democracy in Africa and based in Port Harcourt. He can be reached via festusogwuche@gmail.com
2.3 3 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Emmanuel Joseph

Hmmm ,That is why the Utomi initiative should be judged less by the number of politicians it gathers and more by the institutional quality of the bargain it produces.

Faith Daniel

Coalition government might be the way forward. His maths is not entirely wrong

Adamu Muniratu Eleojo

In my own simple opinion, coalition will definitely have to be worked upon because I think Prof. Pat Utomi’s intitiave should focus on the interest of whatever decision being made rather than being judged ultimately,cus at the end of the day ,this coalition might just help

oluwabunmi mary oluwafunmilayo

This coalition might just work